Things I Learned from my Debut Novel
Guest on May 15 2011 | Filed under: Business, REAL WORLD
Therese here. Please welcome today’s guest, Robin Antalek, author of The Summer We Fell Apart, which was published last year by Harper Collins, called a “well-crafted and cunning debut novel” by Publishers Weekly, and named a Target Breakout Book. The Summer We Fell Apart is the story of four siblings, over the course of fifteen years, who’ve suffered from a neglectful upbringing, and the importance of their connectivity to one another. A story that author Diana Spechler says is ”as haunting as it is gripping.”
Robin’s short fiction has appeared in Five Chapters, 52 Stories, Literary Mama, Sun Dog, among others. She is also a regular contributor at The Nervous Breakdown.
I’m so pleased she’s with us today to talk about lessons learned on the road to publishing her debut novel. Enjoy!
Things I Learned from my Debut Novel
When The Summer We Fell Apart was acquired by Harper Collins, I was shopping in a warehouse store for the anniversary party I was hosting for my in-laws. Propped in my cart was the file folder I had carried across the country all summer crammed with lists and numbers, the caterers’ menu, the party rental place, the cake lady, the flowers, and a list of the miscellaneous items for purchase. My cell rang and it was my agent on the other end with the news. I started to laugh like crazy in the paper goods aisle, until tears came to my eyes. Here was the moment I had been waiting for, and I was surrounded by super-size packages of toilet paper and paper towels. This should have been a warning: I was so not prepared for what was about to happen.
I read early: by three I was sounding out words, four I was reading books, five I was comprehending a few years ahead of my peers. Writing was a natural extension. For years I supplemented my income by writing press releases, radio scripts, and local news pieces. Fiction was for fun as I placed in contests, published in literary journals, and attracted the attention of an agent. Fiction was fun until The Summer We Fell Apart was published, Target picked it up as a Breakout Book and suddenly a lot more people were paying attention.
And I freaked out.
Book clubs came calling, there was a book tour to do with readings and signings, my e-mail box was full of requests and congratulatory letters, some were confessional, readers had connected to the stories of the Haas siblings and wanted to tell me their own. I was in newspapers, on TV, the radio, podcasts and interviewed by NPR and for a while I was on seemingly every virtual blog tour. Suddenly there were critics and Amazon rankings and some not so flattering reviews that dared to wonder how I was allowed to even publish such garbage. People assumed I knew what I was doing and all the while I was floundering. I was grateful for the attention, the sales, the public embrace of the book, but I was sick to death of me. For someone who had spent years writing stories with her imaginary friends, I found myself naked in public.
It’s been eighteen months since publication. I have visited over 70 book groups, given countless readings, met some truly fearless readers, responded to as many notes as possible and I have also learned a few things for next time:
Ignore the inner critic: She will attend every event you do. Be in the moment, be gracious, and be grateful. You didn’t write for the critic, you wrote for yourself. Remember that always. Accept that there will always be someone to point out your faults, and you will be a much saner person.
Keep writing: For a few months I did nothing but attend to the business of my newborn book. It was the most thrilling time of my life, but I was also miserable because I had no head space to write. Finally, I allotted myself an hour before I moved onto the business of my day. It was like prayer, a cleansing breath, and a deep inhale rolled into one.
And yet: Forget about writing book number two. There may be authors who seem super human. They are able to promote one book while writing another. I saw examples of this all over the place and I was making myself nuts playing the comparison game. If you are inspired by all means go for it – but also, give yourself a break. You wrote one book, you can write another in good time.
If there is a mantra for any debut author it should be this: be courageous, be true, be open to everyone, remember the critic is not an indication of your self-worth, keep writing, pay it back where ever you can and above all else, enjoy, for this is truly your moment.
Thanks for a great, Amen-worthy post, Robin! Readers, learn more about Robin and her debut novel, The Summer We Fell Apart, on her website and blog, and by following her on Facebook.
Have a writing mantra you’d like to share? The floor is yours. Write on.
























What a great and timely post! Thank you, in particular for this piece of advice:
“Forget about writing book number two.”
I am breathing a major sigh of relief to learn I’m not the only writer who dares to feel that way. I’m already feeling overwhelmed by the responsibilities of marketing and promoting my upcoming release, and cannot comprehend how I’d be able to concentrate on a new book in the midst of it all. It’s nice to know I’m not the only mere mortal in this game. :)
Thanks again – I really appreciate your candor and insights.
Like?
0
Great advice, Robin!
Like?
0
[...] Writer Unboxed » Things I Learned from my Debut Novel [...]
Like?
0
I take these warnings seriously. I’m actually thankful my journey to being published has been slow (like… going on twenty years). While working to find an agent to represent my first (not really my first) novel, I wrote a second. They both placed in national contests. I found an agent. She wanted to represent both books. While she’s shopping those around, I’m well into writing my third, with a fourth and fifth nudging at me from the wings.
One of my prayers each day is “Thank you Lord for another day to simply write, undistracted.” I cherish each one. And that’s a pretty happy way to live even if all I ever do is cherish each day I have to write for the rest of my life.
Like?
0
It’s great to read such a truthful post. Congratulations on your book!
Like?
0
“It was the most thrilling time of my life, but I was also miserable because I had no head space to write.”
It’s amazing how many authors say that. I suppose I simply cannot imagine how overwhelming publication is. (Can’t wait to find out firsthand for myself. ;)) Thanks for the great advice on how to survive it, and congrats!
Like?
0
Love this! Crying in the toilet paper and paper towel aisle is SUCH a great image! I see it as the opening scene of a movie.
I cried once in a Loblaw’s Super Store in Toronto in the cereal aisle.
Like?
0
Lovely post, Robin! I’m gearing up for the release of my first novel and having a hard time making significant progress on my WIP in the meantime (right now, it’s about 400-500 words a day). Your last tip is refreshing to read.
Like?
0
My first novel, “The Year of the Gadfly” is coming out next year from Houghton-Mifflin. It’s a year away and already I’m freaking out! I wish there was some kind of debut novelists support group. Anybody want to start one? Camille, when’s your book out? Any readings scheduled in NYC?
jen
http://www.byjennifermiller.com
Like?
0
Robin, thank you for such an honest post. It’s exactly what I needed to read right now. I’m sorry to say, this is the first I’ve heard of your book, but it sounds like one I’d like to read. Good luck on your second.
Like?
0
The best, most important sentence in this wonderful piece is, “I was making myself nuts playing the comparison game.” At least it’s the sentence that resonates the most with me.
Writing is about individuality, ultimately. What makes my work different from yours, and King, and Twain is not our ability to type, or our command of the language (although both of those variables can come into play to some degree) it is our ability to be ourselves that makes us attractive to those who read our work.
I like who I am, I like what I write, and I really enjoy the thought process that brings me to putting those words down in an organized manner. The same may be true for you (one would certainly hope so). But what makes us unique is what makes us a delight to our readers. To pretend to be someone else, to write in a style that is awkward and clumsy to us, is to cheapen the experience the reader gets from our work.
As you say, we really write for ourselves. This is our one great indulgence. So thank you for making it clear that playing the comparison game is a fools errand. We are all unique. We should celebrate that, and revel in it. Even if our sales numbers never equal out. That was never why we sat down to write in the first place, was it?
Like?
0
Thank you for this. I haven’t reached the publishing stage yet, but when that happens, I’ll definitely have some advice from the trenches.
Like?
0
So inspirational! Thanks for letting us in on your journey to a published author!
Like?
0
A very honest and hopeful post. Thank you!
Like?
0
Great reminder to “ignore the inner critic”. With my memoir about to launch, and talk of a book tour starting, sometimes I can’t sleep at night worrying about this next phase. Your advice helps tremendously.
Like?
0
Thanks everyone for leaving such thoughtful responses — I’m thrilled to be a part of this discussion. Even in the best of times we all have insecurities.
Like?
0
Great advice, and thank you for sharing it. I loved how you pointed out there will always be critics, and by accepting that fact, we’ll keep our sanity. I also appreciated the part about not comparing yourself to others.
Like?
0
What a helpful post. I think this is the first time I’ve heard someone say, not to write the second book! One always hears just the opposite. It’s nice to get an honest and realistic point of view. Now I have to check out your popular book! Thanks. And best of luck on the second one…when you get around to it…lol…
Like?
0
A most perfect post. My debut novel was released in June 2010, and although my publishing experience has unfolded on a much smaller scale then yours, all the rest most certainly has been running on a parallel track. That nasty inner critic who insists on shouting above every other voice, the sense of loving my novel, but being thoroughly sick of me — the gnawing ache to find a moment to write, constantly wrestling against the known obligation to promote…
Thank you, Robin, for a most timely, honest, and encouraging post. Every once in a while, in the midst of all this madness, I’m learning the importance of taking a moment to pause and put it all into perspective. Something you have done here quite beautifully!
Like?
0
Loved your post but unable to relate to ‘no time to write’. Perhaps my process is different. I ideate a plot line, block out an initial scene sequence then research the relevant facts and write up the scenes, incidences, dialog that will fill out the concept. Ergo, I write the pieces and in no particular order. These can be done in a notebook or a netbook and pieced together and smoothed out later. I guess if I had a process that required me to write in a continuing stream, I would have the same problem as you. But, I don’t.
Like?
0
The old saying “be careful what you wish for” is so true in this business. We all want to be published whether independently, or e-book form, or in print and the excitement and need for marketing that surround that can be so overwhelming as to stunt our ability to write that “next book”. We need to enjoy the ride no matter where we are in the process and not put tons of unneeded pressure on ourselves.
Like?
0
This is a fantastic post! Thanks for sharing your story, and congratulations on the success you have achieved. I have heard many authors talk about how overwhelming it can be to receive this type of attention after working by themselves for so long; you provided some great advice for handling the criticism that will come (from both yourself and others) and staying focused on why we truly write in the first place.
Like?
0
. . . great post, robin! . . .boy, do i feel you on the “sick of myself” front . . . after three months of non-stop touring, and two or three interviews a day, i roll my eyes at the sound of my own voice, which, at this point, can carry on just fine without me . . . and during that time i wrote zero words of fiction . . . BUT, i feel ever-so-grateful to have the opportunity to help myself . . .
Like?
0
I gave a reading last night to a really great crowd and still, I was surprised and sort of humbled that people wanted to come a year and a half after the fact. It all sort of gets jumbled together doesn’t it? The self-loathing and the gratitude that brings us to our knees. It’s also what enables me to get up and do it all over again, still amazed at how this all turned out…
Like?
0
Wow, Robin … thank you for sharing all of this. It’s wonderful to hear of your honest process of moving through the debut of your first novel. Thank you for taking the time to share with many of us the struggles you’ve come through. You’ve strengthened us all!
Godspeed on your next novel!
Jennifer King
Like?
0
Robin, very fine and essential things to remember as my agent goes out shopping with another novel of mine soon. Incidentally, yeah, I lost almost a year of writing time to the promotion of Slut Lullabies–touring, guest-blogging, interviews, etc., and that was an indie publication that . . . well, didn’t get anywhere near Target, ha. But yeah, this stuff takes a lot out of you, and away from the place your focus has been for all the years leading up to it: the writing itself. It’s been so great these past 5 months or so to be back to the writing.
And what better place than some party-paper-goods aisle than to find out such life-changing news? It keeps you connected to the realities of what daily life is often all about, for better and worse. Unless we’re Oprah or JK Rowlings, we’re all destined to spend a lot of time in the paper goods aisles, even if our books sell.It seems perfect.
Like?
0