The Writer’s War
John Vorhaus on Jan 27 2011 | Filed under: CRAFT, Humor
Kath here. Please welcome John Vorhaus to our list of valued contributors. He’s the author of the hilarious novel The California Roll (I call it smartass fic) and the Killer Poker series. John has guest posted with us twice this past year (click HERE and HERE), and we’ve loved his funny voice and valuable insights into publishing. A successful screenplay writer, novelist and humorist, John is sure to bring a different perspective and plenty of laughs to WU. We hope you agree. Take it away, John!
I’ll tell you the truth, if everything were going great in my writer’s life, I wouldn’t be writing this now. But I’m currently facing a challenge common to many writers – maybe one you yourself have faced, or are facing now. See, my last novel, The California Roll, launched with great expectations (and to terrific reviews) last year, but just didn’t perform as well as I (and my publisher!) (and my mother!) had hoped. While I’m inclined to blame this on everything and anything from Kindle to sunspots, the fact remains that what I thought would be an effortless and important jump up the ladder of my career instead turned into something I’m too familiar with: just another battle in the war that is the writer’s life. While there’s hope for the sequel novel, The Albuquerque Turkey (more adventures from master con artist Radar Hoverlander), due out in March, 2011, the circumstances remain the same: It’s fluffing hard to be a writer these days. It’s a battle; worse, it’s a war. And it’s inspired me to share some thoughts on this subject of the battle and the war of the writer’s life.
I start by asking myself a question: Why do I write? Some multiple choice answers come to mind:
A – easy money
B – can’t hold a real job
C – just want my voice to be heard
D – just sort of feel like I have to
I can’t use Answer A – easy money – for that would tab me as either naïve, deluded or perverse, and I’m none of these things (okay, perverse a little, but whatever). Answer B has some merit, for having written myself into the corner that’s called the writer’s life, there’s really not much I hold in the way of alternative marketable skills. It’s not like I can sell cars. Answer C sounds good – I just want my voice to be heard – for that’s true, I do. But the real answer for me is D, I just sort of feel like I have to. Writing is my passion or, on dark days like today, my compulsion. For better or worse, I’m stuck with it. And I know I’m not alone. So not alone. You’re right there with me, too.
So many of us writers feel like we have no choice. We write because something named or nameless inside us makes us write. We often feel frustration because nothing we write seems to quell or quench the urge within. It’s like a virus with a low-grade fever and the antibiotics they give us are crap. So we answer D – just sort of feel like I have to - but we’re not necessarily thrilled with our selection, especially when the huge and fickle monolithic (Neolithic?) marketplace seems not to notice our efforts, honor our compulsion, or even have the decency to treat our virus.
Thus do we live with the constant struggle between the urge to write and the certain knowledge that (more) often (than not) things won’t go the way we hope. That’s the war, the writer’s war.
And war, as we know, is hell.
But writing isn’t hell, not always. Sometimes there are moments of pure glory, and without those moments we’d just walk away, no matter how virally inflected we were. Those moments are the addiction condition of writing; a have more/need more situation, where the more we write, the more we want to write and the more we want our writing to be recognized, lauded, or at least acknowledged. We don’t try to quit. We have no real desire to quit. Nor could we quit anyhow, not with the crap antibiotics they feed us.
Yet here we discover with the force of revelation the most important thing about about the relationship of writers to writing: a thing called choice.
Even though we may feel we have no choice but to write, we always get to exercise the choice of what to write. That’s the best part. That’s where the glory lives, as well as the buzz – the buzz of having the pure power to choose. This is an awesome power, truly a godlike one. Better, it’s a power that no editor, publisher, producer, partner, agent, loved one, critic, boss, reviewer, client, buyer or pet can ever take away. We might modify our choices to serve other people’s needs, or serve the market, but ultimately it’s our brain that’s driving our hands and bringing our words to life. Without choice, writing is just a thousand-yard stare into the endless void of an empty page.
Anyone can face an empty page.
It takes a writer to fill it.
So recognize your power – that marvelous power to choose – and own it. And believe me, I’m saying this as much to me as I am to you. Own it all. Own the right to start stories you don’t finish. Own the authority to create characters you later kill off. Own the initiative to try forms of writing you’ve never tried before. Own control over the most basic question, the only one that really matters, really: What do I want to write right now? Above all, own your right to be wrong on the page. Be confident in knowing that choices improve as information improves – and that wrong choices lead to right choices in the end.
We get to choose. That’s what makes us writers, and makes other poor jlubs people who sell cars. We choose; we discover and judge; we select. In sum, we create. By making choices.
Yay, us! No, seriously, yay, us!
The writer’s war is the struggle to make choices without going nuts. Without doubting ourselves, annoying ourselves, stopping or subverting or diverting ourselves. If we succeed, then we communicate our thoughts to others in meaningful ways, or even just fanciful ones. If we fail… sigh… we try again, because we’re writers and we can’t stop writing. But even if we succeed, we… sigh… still try again, because we’re writers, and being writers is just not enough. We not only have to start being writers, we have to keep being writers. That’s the virus, and there’s no known cure.
Bottom line: It gonna be a damn long war.
A war we often feel like we’re fighting alone. Writing, after all, is a largely solitary undertaking, and the problems we face (plot problems, money problems, confidence problems – oh, that list goes on and on) seem such isolated and isolating ones. But we’re not alone, not really. We share the company of everyone who’s walked the writer’s path before us, and everyone who’ll ever walk it next. If that assurance seems less than assuasive to you, please consider that there are tangible allies, too, and please consider me one of them if you will. I welcome your direct outreach at johnvorhaus at yahoo dot com, or through this site, or maybe our paths will cross at Starbucks. I might also respectfully point you to my two books on writing, The Comic Toolbox and Creativity Rules (from which some of these thoughts have been most shamelessly poached). My books – my own words – have helped me fight the writer’s war from time to time; I flatter myself that they might help you, too.
But you know what? Don’t take my word for it – take your word for it. Take your eyes off this page right now and put them on a blank one. Fill that page, and see if you don’t feel better about yourself – and know more about yourself – than you did when you began. If it takes five minutes, or fifteen, or fifty, it’ll be time well spent because nothing spells writer like words on the page. And nothing gets a writer high like exercising the power to choose.
And the way I see it is: if writing is my addiction, the least it can do is get me high.






















I’m right there with you. At dinner with some writer/agent friends I commented that I have to write; getting published is just gravy. My friend seemed surprised. “Really? Just gravy?” I responded, “Well…really, really GOOD gravy.” The truth is, if no publisher ever picks up one of my books, I’d still have a WIP covering my desk and a notebook by my bedside. “Compulsion” was your word. I like it.
Like?
0
This was a well thought out and written post, John.
Really enjoyed your perspective on writing and how it’s a war, something we battle on a daily basis.
One thing though. I’m thinking your comment,
blame this on everything and anything from Kindle to sunspots
…was in jest, because the Kindle has done wonderful things for writers and their products.
I have never had a literary agent or a deal with the Big Six, but due to the Kindle’s emerging force, I am now a stay-at-home writer.
An independently published author on the Kindle is beating the Dragon Tattoo series on the Top 100. She’s got three books in the Top 11.
So there is money to be made and the Kindle is helping authors make it.
Like?
0
Great post! There’s just no walking away from it. Even in the really hard times, if we were meant to write, it stays with us.
Like?
0
What a great post and so apropos for me as I sit facing yet another set of revisions. I was just going to start feeling sorry for myself but hooray! I am not alone. Thanks, John.
Like?
0
John, I see where you’re going with this ‘power to choose’ theme, but, to me, there’s a catch. Stephen King, in On Writing, said his most asked query is ‘Why horror?’ His simple answer: “What makes you think I have a choice?” I’ve begun telling people that story when I’m asked ‘Why historic fantasy?’
I have seen, in a powerful way, that my writing suffers if it is not drawn from the deep recesses of my heart. For me, writing is more about that ‘drawing out’ process than about filling the page with chosen words. Lucky inner-calling for King, a bit less so for me.
Having said that, I recently had your revelation illustrated to me. When I set out, I intended my WIP to be a novella. I was angushed for days, weeks even, this winter over keeping it brief enough. Finally, my wife said the simple words, “Who cares? It’s your choice. If it’s not working short, make it another novel.” Ahhh, so simple. Choice.
Thanks for the reminder.
Like?
0
Thanks for this, John. I feel so much better having read it. Was just preparing a post for my own blog about the never-ending feeling of having some sort of carrot dangling in front of me (as a writer) that I just can’t ever seem to reach. I’ll still write it, but my mood and tone will be a heck of a lot more positive now remembering that I’m not alone!
I also noted with interest your use of the word “career” in relation to writing — something else I want to blog about at some point. This word has always struck me as simply wrong. Writing is a path, a vocation, a way of life, kind of like parenthood. But like parenthood, I just can’t justify calling it a career. There’s nothing linear about its progression, it comes in strange fits and spurts often with decade-long hiatuses in between (think, Marilynne Robinson, Ahrundati Roy…)and sure doesn’t pay the way a traditional “career” does. Our expectations as writers have been shaped to some extent by this word “career,” but a serious reassessment is needed!
Like?
0
John: Yeah, it’s a long war, and there’re a lot of downs with the ups, even for writers such as Mark Twain. Here’s what Twain had to listen to from publisher George Carleton, standing there in Carleton’s office after Twain had submitted several stories, including The Jumping Frog of Calaveras County: “Books—look at those shelves. Every one of them is loaded with books that are waiting for publication. Do I want any more? Excuse me, I don’t. Good morning.” If Twain had bad patches, I suppose we should expect them, too. Keep pounding the keys.
Like?
0
Just yesterday, I was on the phone with my agent who was telling me we’d come to the end of the road trying to sell my novel to publishers. A sad, defeating conversation.
The question hanging in the air was, “what will I write next?” My agent had all kinds of ideas, as have my supportive friends and mom. But nothing felt more empowering and got me back on the ol’ horse than being able to say, “when I decide, I’ll get back to you.”
Writing is the only thing in life I have complete control over yet completely enjoy. It’s mine.
Thanks for sharing, Vorhaus! I sincerely wish you all the best with your next book.
Like?
0
Well, this will sound like I’m sucking-up — and who’s kidding, I probably am at the subconscious level — but I love me some smart-ass fiction and I read California Roll just last week. Both it and the MC held such joie de vivre that I ordered your writing books, too. (Which would be fab if they were available through the Kindle. I’m just sayin’.)
Re choice: you know, the thing is, no matter how I want to commit suicide-by-keyboard at times, I don’t think I’d choose the childhood vaccine; I just don’t. Course, that could be the encephalitis talking. ;)
Like?
0
“Own the right to start stories you don’t finish. Own the authority to create characters you later kill off. Own the initiative to try forms of writing you’ve never tried before. Own control over the most basic question, the only one that really matters, really: What do I want to write right now?”
Thank you for that.
Like?
0
You speak for us all, my man. We beat our boats against the waves, as F. Scott so famously said. It is a mindless drive akin to the reproductive urge with all its messy needs and consequences. But, deny it? Not in my lifetime.
Like?
0
Nicely done. I especially liked this:
Anyone can face an empty page.
It takes a writer to fill it.
And your words on choice were impactful. I’ve put off (avoided?) starting a new project for a couple of years, spending my time instead on polishing existing works to a gloss.
Part of the problem has been that none of the notions I’ve come up with have had the aroma of the catnip it takes to really suck me into Yes, I can do that! and Yes, I want to do that! and Yes, I have to do that!
And then I remembered a concept that bubbled up months ago for which I felt, for a moment at least, all of those things.
So tonight I’ll unearth those notes and see if the allure is still there.
Thanks.
Like?
0
I just love how you pinpoint the writer’s true power: choice. At the very simplest letter, a writer is somebody who chooses words. She looks at the entire 200,000+ words in the English language and decides which dozen or so will go into a particular sentence. That’s something to celebrate, and certainly something to turn to in a time when being a writer seems like a losing battle.
Like?
0
Well said! If any of us are writing without option D–feeling like we have to, or even just feeling like we *want* to–then we should really just quit. Unless our talent is so astounding that we’re sure to make millions no matter what we put out. But those cases are, I’m sure, few and far between, and I’m still not sure I’d want a job I hate, even if it makes me rich. Of course, if I were rich, I’d have no reason to continue writing, which brings us back to the idea of quitting if you don’t have the passion and internal propelling force implicit in option D!
Like?
0
i followed a link from a friend’s facebook page and here i am. i also rooted around your personal page (STALKER!) and when i saw the bottle of tona, i gasped. i had a six-pack of that delish beer many moons ago and then was informed by my local joint that they could no longer get it for me. best beer. yurm. yet, then so sad.
so there you have it. aren’t you glad you slogged thru this silly comment? (i’ll answer that: yeah, you are!)
Like?
0
“Anyone can face an empty page.
It takes a writer to fill it.”
That (and the next paragraph) were my fave parts. I felt so… CHARGED, after reading this! Thank you.
Like?
0
Thank you for sharing such encouragement, especially with those of us who are still unpublished. Cheers!
Like?
0
Marvelous! Thank you so much for this post — it was just what I needed.
Like?
0
As writers, we all hit those moments, those ‘why on earth am I still doing this against all odds?’; ‘where is this ever going?’; where did this friggin’ dream come from?’ moments. It’s nice to know all writers have these, and you’re absolutely right that the awesome writer moments – though sometimes few and far between – make it worth it.
Thanks so much for the inspiration!
Like?
0
I love reading posts like this–they are not only inspiring, but always help me to keep in mind that being a writer is not as solitary a process as it once was. Writing is an addiction for me too, and without my fix, I feel sorry for those who have to be around me, LOL, *snorts. Thanks for the inspiring words! Writing is a war, and all I can say, is bring it on!
Like?
0