Love at First Read
Erika Robuck on Aug 15 2010 | Filed under: CRAFT
What is about that first encounter that pulls you in?
Is it his penetrating eyes, the way he looks over the side of his shoulder at you, his confidence? Is it how she runs her ring finger along the side of her lipstick, the way she takes dinner to the old man down the hall, her intelligence?
Why all this talk of love in a writing blog? Because being able to make your audience respond emotionally to your protagonist vests them in the story, and keeps them turning pages.
I took a sampling of some bestsellers to find out how the authors made us fall in love at first sight (or first chapter, or first prologue) with their protagonists. For the purposes of this post, the definition of love includes the obsessive, the maternal, the romantic and beyond. In all cases, however, the characters stir something in the belly. While love is highly individual, the widespread popularity of the following books shows that there are ways to appeal to the masses.
The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Society by Mary Ann Shaffer & Annie Barrows
This post-WW2, epistolary novel is about a writer, Juliet, who travels to the English Channel Island of Guernsey to meet a group who used books to help them through the German occupation. Juliet’s sense of humor, capriciousness, and ability to laugh at herself instantly endear her to the reader. In one of her opening letters she says, “I know that I am fortunate to have any place at all to live in London, but I much prefer whining to counting my blessings.” Such quips are frequent in the book, and add lightness to its serious themes.
The Help by Kathryn Stockett
This Civil Rights era novel written from the point of view of an irresistible trio of strong, Southern voices was the runaway bestseller and most popular book club choice of 2009. It’s the little remarks about household chores, “She already got the blue dress on I ironed this morning, the one with sixty-five pleats on the waist…I don’t hate much in life, but me and that dress is not on good terms,” and employer judgment, “she is the laziest woman I’ve ever seen. Including my sister Doreena who never lifted a royal finger growing up because she had the heart defect that we later found out was a fly on the X-ray machine,” that reveal the personalities of the narrators, and earn our esteem.
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark Haddon
This murder mystery novel, narrated by an autistic 15-year old boy, has one of the most endearing protagonists of recent years. From the onset of the book the reader feels protective of Christopher who knows “every prime number to 7,057” and likes dogs because they are “faithful and they do not tell lies because they cannot talk.” After being wrongly accused of the murder of his neighbor’s dog, Christopher attempts to acquit himself by solving the mystery. The author is able to maintain the narrator’s voice, without exploiting him, and what results is a compulsively readable book with a truly loveable narrator.
How about you? Can you think of any characters you’ve loved at first read? How do you make your own characters appealing?
*Photo courtesy of Deviant Art’s Olino.





















[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Todd Rutherford, Phaze Books. Phaze Books said: #writing Love at First Read: What is about that first encounter that pulls you in? Is it his penetrating eyes, the… http://bit.ly/d4Wj86 [...]
Like?
0
A while back I got sucked in to the Stephanie Plum series–I loved Stephanie right from the start because of her love of spandex and big hair.
Like?
0
I know I’m going really old-school on this one, but I absolutely loved Ishmael from Moby Dick. As a narrator, he was honest and vulnerable right from the opening line. And always slightly unreliable. “Call me Ishmael” says, just as clearly, “Ishmael might not be my real name.” Throughout the book, I desperately want this guy to succeed in whatever it is he’s doing. Beyond the adventure of the hunt, there’s this underlying change affecting Ishmael that just makes me shake my head in wonder at Melville’s talent.
Like?
0
Those are three of my favourite books!
My addition to the list is Mma Ramotswe from the No.1 Ladies’ Detective Agency series by Alexander McCall Smith. Her honesty, kindness and positive view of people are so endearing that I don’t think anyone could avoid falling in love with her. I also love the way she’s always referring to her ‘traditional’ figure, being proud and self-conscious of it at the same time.
Like?
0
I think one of the most important qualities in all these characters is that they tell the truth to themselves (if not to everyone around them).
Like?
0
Everyone’s comments so far seem to be in line with mine. The man I think I first fell in love with (and he’s old enough to be my father) was Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird. It’s his caring attitude, quiet and patient, towards his children. Yet he’s firm: “Sometimes it’s better to bend the lauw a little in special cases, Scout. In your case, the law remains rigid. So to school you must go.”
Like?
0
I like characters with values that I respect in real people. A pretty woman is much more appealing as a character if she is also likable and good hearted. A male character however can be a little bad… I tend to be a little more lenient with the male characters. :D
Like?
0
Oh my goodness, I have heard good things about THE HELP but nothing has convinced me to read it so much as this line:
“I don’t hate much in life, but me and that dress is not on good terms.”
Thank you!!
And yes, good points about making readers fall in love with characters. Sometimes it’s done too shallowly and we don’t fall for it — just talking about how everyone ELSE in the book loves a certain characters is not enough for me — but when a character is painted with traits that I admire, such as honor or courage, or humor, or just pure kindness, THEN I will fall for them. Case in point: Katniss Everdeen of the HUNGER GAMES. I adore her. I’m even rereading her story, and I *rarely* reread whole books (usually just scenes).
Like you, I’m looking to the masters (Suzanne Collins w/ Katniss) as I think about how to endear my next set of characters to my readers. :)
Like?
0
Christopher of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time is probably my favorite character in adult fiction. Actually, looking at my keeper shelf, my favorite books all contain memorable characters I fell for.
Great post, Erika!
Like?
0
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by ThereseWalsh, Erika Robuck. Erika Robuck said: I'm guest blogging at Writer Unboxed today. Stop by & tell me what makes you love your favorite characters:… http://fb.me/xL6CUrZ1 [...]
Like?
0
And what about the long suffering British detective Lord Peter Whimsey and his love Harriet Vane? Great series of books by Dorothy L Sayers and amazing tension in building a love relationship.
Sheila is correct … the men can be a little naughty and still command our respect.
Like?
0
It’s rare that I find a book where I truly love the characters. The Help, for the most part, was one of them. One reason is I actually love characters whom I can also hate, but these days, there are so many coockie-cutter “Mr.-nice-guy” likeable characters out there. Many of the The Help’s characters had unlikeable sides that I loved to hate! Isn’t reading a lot more fun when your nerves prickle with discomfort over the way the characters are thinking and acting — just like they do in real life — at least at some point?
Like?
0
[...] secrets. (Note: Erika Robuck blogged about this over at Writer Unboxed, specifically discussing characters, and how authors make you fall in love with them.) Good or bad, as a writer, you can take something from any book. Maybe the prose was beautiful [...]
Like?
0
Great comments and suggestions, all!
Justin, you may have inspired me to finally try MOBY DICK.
Kristan, that was the line that had me, too.
Sharon, I agree with your love/hate relationship with characters. Juliet in THE GUERNSEY book jumps out to me as a very flawed character, but it almost makes you love her all the more when you want to smack her.
Like?
0
George Smiley in the John Le Carre series got to me. You would read along,lulled by his seeming disconnectedness then, wham!, he suddenly becomes authoritative and assertive and you realize what all that intelligence has been up to. Le Carre is the master at setting up and conducting interviews and meetings that are pregnant with undercurrents and sly maneuverings.
Like?
0
At the risk of everyone giving a collective “ew – are you nuts?”…
Dagny Taggart in Atlas Shrugged. Even though Rand’s descriptions are spartan and cold, I was drawn to Dagny’s confidence.
Like?
0
I’m away from home right now, but now you have me curious about first lines that pull me in to the character specifically, rather than just the voice or premise. Interesting exercise.
As for what I recall, I don’t necessarily have to admire the character to find them compelling, but they need to feel or desire something passionately, even if they would deny it with their last breath. I love characters with internal conflict.
Like?
0
“…they need to desire something passionately…”
Well said, Jan!
Like?
0
I havent read all those books but I am very much interested if readin them. Hope I can find a copy of those three :)
Like?
0
Great post, E! The characters I enjoy and enjoy writing are the ones that do or say what I wish I could do in real life. They have their faults which makes them endearing but they also say the things that I think of but always a moment too late. After the situation is over, I think “Darn it! I should have said blah, blah, blah…”
I am going to pull Claire out of Outlander as one of those characters. Perhaps because I am finishing the last book in the series right now but I love her smart mouth, smart mind, and passion for life.
Great to see you back on here!
Like?
0