Editing: An Enlightened Approach
Guest on Jun 27 2010 | Filed under: CRAFT
Please welcome Erika Liodice, who was a semi-finalist in WU’s search for an unpubbed contributor. She wrote:
Like many writers, I wrote my first book when I was 5 or 6 years old. It was a story about a little girl with 18 brothers and sisters who had to share one bathroom (talk about conflict!). You’ll probably be surprised to hear that it was never picked up for publication. (Shocking, I know.)I started seriously pursuing fiction writing four years ago. In that time I’ve completed two novels. Writing my first novel was like losing my literary virginity; I unknowingly did everything wrong, naively thought it was great and now just wish I could forget the whole ordeal.
Even though my first book failed to grab the attention of a literary agent, it did serve to teach me firsthand about the writing process and the business. Most importantly, it showed me how much I still needed to learn. Since then, I’ve invested a great deal of time and money into developing my craft through writing classes, conferences and dozens of books on the subject. Now, as I work through the editing process with my second novel, I feel much more confident about my manuscript’s chances to jump out of the slush pile and turn heads.
We know you’ll enjoy Erika’s post on editing as much as we did.
Editing: An Enlightened Approach
When it came to my first book (which is now safely locked in my desk drawer), I was so excited to “get ‘er done” that I really didn’t want to think about editing at all. I just wanted to jump straight to the good part: getting an agent and signing a book deal. But I’ve come to learn that agents and book deals only come to writers who put in the work up front. So today I’m going to share with you my enlightened approach to editing, which I’m following as I revise my new book.
One of the biggest lessons I’ve learned is that your first draft is NOT the place to edit yourself (although it’s very tempting). As a writing instructor once told me, “A novel sprout is a very delicate thing and too early or vigorous of a critique can damage it.” A first draft is about one thing and one thing only: getting words down on paper. Sometimes those words will be masterful works of art and other times they’ll just plain suck. But that’s all right because that’s what first drafts are for.
Of course, once your first draft is done, then the real work begins. It’s been said that most writing is rewriting, which brings us to the first phase of my enlightened editing process, a phase I like to think of as “big picture editing”. Imagine yourself at an art museum admiring a painting from twenty feet back. “Ah, yes, they’re water lilies,” you might say of Monet’s infamous oil series. Big picture editing works much the same way; you read through your work and evaluate it from twenty feet back. Think about the story as a whole, capitalize on its strengths and fix its weaknesses. Analyze your theme, plot, setting, characters, point of view, pacing, and structure. This is not the time to nitpick or worry about the fact that you’ve used the same word twice in one sentence. This is the time to make sure Dalí’s melting clocks didn’t make their way into your water lily pond.
Next come the “middle drafts”, which are like looking at the painting from 8-10 feet away. You’re still observing the work as a whole, but the details – the reflections in the pond, the contrast of the blues against the greens – come into focus. During this phase, dive into each scene and make sure your characters, descriptions, dialogue, pacing, voice and style bring your story to life, propel it forward and capture the reader’s attention.
The final phase is like standing in front of the painting with your nose an inch from the canvas. You’re no longer looking at the piece as a whole but examining each individual brush stroke. This “close-up” editing is where you analyze every word and sentence, rewriting them until they’re flawless. This is the time for all that nitpicking you’ve been dying to do. It’s also the time to channel your grade school English lessons, making sure your spelling, grammar and punctuation are impeccable. The goal here is to ensure that your ideas are clearly written and that your prose isn’t littered with unnecessary words.
I should warn you, making revisions can become addicting and if you don’t cut yourself off at some point, you might be making tweaks forever. Knowing when your manuscript is officially done is often nothing more than a gut feeling, but by following a thorough editing process you can rest assured that every word adds to the overall strength of your masterpiece.
Photo courtesy Flickr’s HarshLight





















Wonderful pointers. Thanks for providing me with yet more tools to help with my writing.
Leah
Like?
0
Excellent comparison and advice. :)
Like?
0
Interesting process. I don’t think I followed any one of those steps!
Marc Vun Kannon
http://authorguy.wordpress.com/
Like?
0
Oh, so true. I find myself obsessing about comma placement immediately after draft one and have to SLAP myself.
Like?
0
[...] In other news, today is my debut on Writer Unboxed!! Check it out: “Editing: An Enlightened Approach” [...]
Like?
0
Excellent analogy, and something I’ll need to remember as I begin to dig into my ms revisions. Thanks for laying this out in such a clear way.
Like?
0
Oh, I so cringed in sympathy at your description of your first novel writing experience. I was just the same. Great advice, too! Although every writer is different, and I have to say that the just-get-the-words-onto-the-page first draft method doesn’t work for me at all, and I tend to go through all of your editing steps for every paragraph and scene I write. But you’re absolutely right, writing is re-writing, no matter how you go about it! Great post.
Like?
0
Always like the ties between art and literature.
Your article helps me to see the forest and the tries, whoever painted them!
Like?
0
All so true — and the part about knowing when to stop is so important. A friend of mine who BTW won a National Book Award always says: ‘if you go too far with your editing, you’ll massacre it!”
Like?
0
“A novel sprout is a very delicate thing and too early or vigorous of a critique can damage it.”
This is why I never allow anyone to read my 1st drafts and why I never discuss even my ideas with other people until I’m in the late stages of revision. I don’t brainstorm with other people about novel ideas, either!
Your ideas about big-picture, middle and close-up editing reminded me of when I did paper evaluations as a tutor at my university’s writing center. Look at the global picture first. After all, if you’re just going to have to delete that entire page, who gives a rip about comma placement? Otherwise, you’re wasting your time.
Like?
0
“Writing my first novel was like losing my literary virginity; I unknowingly did everything wrong, naively thought it was great and now just wish I could forget the whole ordeal.”
LOL!
What an excellent metaphor! Thanks for sharing this wonderful post. :)
Like?
0
Very true!
I have only recently discovered how delicate a thing my ‘novel sprouts’ are, which has caused me to rework my novel writing procedure – cutting off all outside access to my first draft. At least until I’ve decided I’m going to ditch it and start again. Then I distract my family with number one while I slink off and write draft 2.
Thank you for your great suggestions. I’m going to come back and read this each time I start a new edit sweep, just to make sure I’m at the right stage. ;)
Like?
0
Thanks for the nice comparison to a seedling. That’s such an appropriate analogy.
I structure my editing like you suggest. I also use the AutoCrit Editing Wizard during the middle and final phases. It helps keep me in line :-)
Like?
0
This is a wonderful description of the editing process. It’s something I’ve been doing, but I didn’t have a great way of explaining it, until now! The visual is an excellent one, so now every time I’m editing, I will know which stage I’m on by what I can “see” in the painting before me. :)
Like?
0
Agree with the visual–that image is staying with me!
Like?
0
Wow, this hit home for me! I am writing my first book and feel like I have to make the first draft great from the start. It is paralyzing at times. What a great analogy with the painting. It totally helped me see the process of drafting and revising in a whole new light. Thank you so much for sharing!
Like?
0
I love, love, love the analogy to viewing the Monet painting from afar, then closer and closer. Spot on. And the obsessive/compulsive editing and revising is something I’m afflicted with. I’m self-publishing on CreateSpace, having just submitted my formatted manuscript and I was editing up until the moment I hit the “submit” button. It’s good to know I’m not alone.:-)
Like?
0
“A novel sprout is a very delicate thing and too early or vigorous of a critique can damage it.”
This is so true. Regretfully, I’ve learned this out of bitter experience. I’ve probably been the unintentional cause of some sprout blighting, too.
Also, what do you have against Dali clocks? ;-)
Like?
0
Ah, first drafts. I’m so glad I can type at light speed, because it allows me to write my first drafts quickly, but not sloppily. I do tend to edit the sentences as I write them, so if something doesn’t look good at first, I backspace and reword, or delete. But, aside from those instant edits, I try not to look at any big-picture stuff until the first draft is complete.
Thanks for sharing your process!
Like?
0
For someone like me to is looking to absorb as much as they can about writing and how to go about getting those words down on the page this is great.
Like?
0
I could stay in your “final phase” forever…searching for just the right word. That’s my favorite part. I think maybe it’s also valuable to finish that “up-close” draft and then step back again to see how the big picture hangs together. Larger units like paragraphs, scenes, and chapters are always fair game…even when I think surely the revision process is completely over!
Like?
0