Crisis Point
Anna Elliott on Apr 16 2010 | Filed under: CRAFT, Inspirations
This time it will be different. I say that to myself every time I start writing a new book. This time, I think, I know exactly what I’m writing about, and I’ll get it right on the first try. This time I’ve got a plan that will be the writerly equivalent of a magic spell allowing me to rap three times on the keyboard and have a letter-perfect book simply pour through my fingertips onto the screen.
I guess you only need to look at the title of this post to know how that all ultimately turns out. In a word, Ha.
Oh, it works for awhile. At first, in the first flush of new-story excitement, the words pour onto the page almost as fast as I can type. It’s going so well, I e-mail my best friend writing partner. I’m so excited about this book! I’m having so much fun!
And then . . . and then that flood of new words starts to dry up. And the words I’ve already written start to give off a smell. You know the one I mean? It’s like the faint odor of a potato salad that’s been in the back of the fridge a day too long: not horrible, but at the same time, hopelessly, irredeemably, on it’s way to being bad.
And that’s when I hit what I call the 30,000 word crisis point. The point I always begin a book thinking I will avoid this time around. And the point I always, inevitably, plow straight into like an express train hitting the car parked across its tracks. Every writer is different, but for me, I hit 30,000 words and like clockwork realize that I’m going to have to scrap a sizable chunk of what I’ve written and start all over again.
But you know what? I’m beginning to think that’s actually a good thing.
I do outline before I begin a book, and I do make fairly detailed background sketches of my characters, as well. And yet every sentence, every scene I write teaches me something new about my characters and the journey they’re on. I was just reading a book called “Lion Hunt” to my three-year old, about two little girls who set out on an adventure saying, “We’re going on a lion hunt, we’re going to catch a big one.” And then they run up against various obstacles—like a muddy swamp or whatever—and each time they say, “Can’t go over it. Can’t go around it. Have to go through it. Squish, squish, squish.”
I think writing a book is like that. As much as I wish there were a way over it or around it, there’s simply no other way to get to know your characters and your story but by going through the writing of it—squishing your way through the mud of a daily session in your story world. After writing a good portion of your story, you WILL know your characters far, far better than you did when you started. And that affects the story you’re telling about them, makes it truer, more vital, more real and alive. How can it not?
So if you’re like me and have hit a crisis point in your own work in progress, don’t give up. Don’t even despair. I hit the crisis point in my book this past month—and though it may never get any easier to avoid, it has, at least, gotten easier to accept with each book I’ve written. Ah, I thought. The 30,000 word crisis. Time to go back to the beginning. But I’ll get there.
You will, too.
Image by ~asialiv.





















Crisis is what keeps us growing! In writing, and in life… Two steps forward, one step back. Sometimes more. Enjoy the ride.
Like?
0
OH. MY. GOD. I love you right now. Like, so, so much. Because not only did I hit a crisis point, but it came at 30,000 WORDS!
So knowing that this is common for you, for other writers, for published writers? That’s heaven. Or, you know, at least it pulls me out of hell.
Thank you.
(Also, the image you found for this post is pretty neat.)
Now I’m off to push past the crisis point…!
.-= Kristan´s last blog ..Author Interview: Todd Newton, Part 2 =-.
Like?
0
…there’s simply no other way to get to know your characters and your story but by going through the writing of it—squishing your way through the mud of a daily session in your story world.
Truer words were never spoken. Loved this essay, Anna. Thank you!
Like?
0
Great Post! So nice to hear that others out there notice that semi-rancid smell emanating from the early pages of their WIP…it comforts me!
Thanks for showing us that even published writers are as scared as we are!
Like?
0
Another very productive and popular author I know says she hits the wall at page 151 every single time. She knows it will happen, but still despairs about finishing the book.
I don’t plot too much in advance, so my snags seem to be more random.
Like?
0
“So knowing that this is common for you, for other writers, for published writers? That’s heaven. Or, you know, at least it pulls me out of hell.” – Kristan
Yeah, that’s what I meant!
Like?
0
[...] over at Writer Unboxed today. Stop on [...]
Like?
0
I’m so glad it’s not just me! A lot of my writer friends are astounded at my production on a new idea – I love fresh starts when the ideas are brilliant and the writing, well, writes itself. Then, sure enough, around 30,000 words the ideas are sounding cliche and holes are appearing in my amazing plot and subplot. And the writing – no longer writes itself. In fact, I believe it goes on strike!
Push through – got it!
BTW – The Lion Hunt ~ as a teacher in another life, I loved singing ‘Going on a Bear Hunt’ with the kids and doing the hand gestures. So much fun – thanks for reminding me of that :)
.-= Janet´s last blog ..Friday Fiction – Mickey Spencer, AC ~ Part 8 =-.
Like?
0
Wow. I think the same thing every time I start a new book. I’ll know where I’m going and won’t get sidetracked and blah blah blah. But I hit the wall every single time. Glad I’m not alone!
Like?
0
It’s always 30,000 words! With my last manuscript, that was the exact moment I realized I had started too early, despite my meticulous outlines and character sheets, and that I would have to scrap a big portion of everything I’d already done. Realizing it’s somewhat normal, or at least not bad, is a good step to feeling undefeated–especially when someone well-meaning asks you how far along you are, and you don’t want to say you’re back at 5,000 words after you’ve been writing for a month or two.
Like?
0
you hit the nail on the head with this one! thanks for the encouragement! t
Like?
0
At about 35k, I scrapped 5k. I didn’t want to! But so much better for it.
What is with that 30k number, I wonder?
.-= Jewel/Pink Ink´s last blog ..For Sale =-.
Like?
0
What a great post, Anna! I love the ‘new idea’ part of writing, but the crisis point appears to be inevitable. Nice to know none of us are alone in this :)
.-= Sarah Woodbury´s last blog ..Surprise Holy Day Attack! =-.
Like?
0
Wow, this is why I love Writer Unboxed! I wrote this post hoping I wasn’t alone–but I had no idea just how (wonderfully!) not alone I was on this. Thanks, everyone! And write on! I have no idea why 30k should be the magic number–a post for another day, maybe! ;-)
And Kristan, I love the image, too, but I can’t take credit–that goes to our fabulous co-founder Kathleen, who is positively amazing at matching up images and posts on a daily basis here.
Like?
0
Oh, so true. Just wrapping up novel no. 3 – really thought I’d have it down by now (funny, no?). Though I have to say I’ve learned a lot about myself and writing on a deadline with this book. Who knows what will happen with book 4!
.-= Hillary Manton Lodge´s last blog ..Over the Airwaves. Kinda. =-.
Like?
0
That “Lion Hunt” quote is perfect. It’s true for pretty much everything in life and especially with writing.
Before I started writing my first novel, I thought there was a formula for doing this. And since I didn’t know the magic formula, I delayed writing. I don’t know what changed, but I finally got sick of waiting for the perfect process and just started writing. Since then, that is how I keep myself going. I say to myself, “Just write.”
.-= Rebecca @ Diary of a Virgin Novelist´s last blog ..From baseball to beer to books =-.
Like?
0
I do love that Lion Hunt quote. “We’re going to catch a big one.” I know it’s from a children’s book, but that would be a strong opening line for a novel.
Anyways… So am I the only writer who hits a wall about every 5,000 words?
Like?
0
This is so true, except I hit my wall earlier, usually around 18-20k. I have to “write my way in”, then I hit that point and realize where I REALLY need to go instead of the direction I’m headed and have to go back and rework, lol. Great post.
.-= Roni @ FictionGroupie´s last blog ..He Said, She Said: Dialogue and Potential Blogfest =-.
Like?
0
Yes! Mine tends to come a bit later but it does come. And while it’s very disappointing to have to start from the beginning, I completely agree with you. I always feel like I know my characters much better than when I started and with each new draft, I get a little further and it gets better and better. Thanks for this post!
.-= Stormy´s last blog ..Notebook: Give a Little, Take a Little =-.
Like?
0
Hi, I have to admit I chuckled at your opening. although I don’t have kids, I think it’s like having your second child. You know it’s going to be really painful and gross. But, you do it anyway with a ton of optimism and joy.
Thanks for this
Like?
0
Let me see… Writing takes presence over perfect housekeeping; finds quotes from kids’ books to be some of the best resources; willing to own the nature of her hope must shift.
Yup. Writer Unboxed at its finest. Thank you for this.
.-= Jan O’Hara´s last blog ..Muse Is Not the Boss of Me =-.
Like?
0
I’m one of those writers that strays far and wide from the outline. So much so, at certain key points I have to go back to previous pages and read over certain elements of characters.
The thing is, this type of writing works for me. It keeps everything fresh and energized. Otherwise I worry about forcing the plot and storyline. By the 30,ooo mark my characters have taken the reigns and end up taking me places I hadn’t even thought to go.
I’ll admit there are times I have to step back for a day or so and let the story breathe, or I get stuck on too many details in the first draft; instead of remembering letting the 1st draft tell the story and fill in the details in the 2nd, 3rd, and if necessary 4th draft. (Hugs)Indigo
.-= Indigo´s last blog ..Escaping the Asylum of my Mind =-.
Like?
0
In my current WIP I hit that point at 40,000 words. My life was insane at the time, and I couldn’t figure out how to fix the ms, so I put it away and wrote another. Had few problems with it, although it hasn’t sold yet. I’m back to the other, and figured out where I’d written myself into a ditch. Well, several ditches. Tossed some scenes, dumped some characters, and began anew–and finished. Now I’m rewriting.
.-= Valerie´s last blog ..Fashionista =-.
Like?
0
Beautifully written. Beautifully inspiring. I suppose we all have our crisis points–whatever they may be. It’s just so nice to have a community of others in emotional peril… ; )
Write on!
.-= Anne´s last blog ..Mad Scientist Experiments in P.O.V. =-.
Like?
0
Perry, funny you should mention the second child analogy, because I just had my second baby and that’s exactly it–tons of optimism and joy, of course. But all the same, the second time around you know EXACTLY how much it’s going to hurt.
And Jan, don’t get me wrong–I dream of the day when the writing/housekeeping choice won’t be a basically either/or proposition, when I’ll actually have time for both. But with a three year old, an infant, and a book newly out? That day is feeling a long way off! :)
Like?
0
This must be a universal thing for writers, considering so many people seem to have had the same problem (myself included).
I happen to be at about 32,000 words right now, and I’m struggling. Not because I don’t have any more story to write, but because I’m starting to second-guess my entire plot.
Is it good enough? Am I trying to add too many story elements? Have I left out an important sub-plot?
It’s the point at which a writer says to herself, “I’m in too deep to quit now, but am I on the right path?”
Here’s to hoping we all find our way (sooner, rather than later)!
.-= Suzannah´s last blog ..How to Motivate Yourself to Write When You’re Tired =-.
Like?
0
It so helps to know that you are not the only one! You still have to slog through it but if others can so I. Thanks, Anne.
Like?
0
Great post! I agree, writing is tough, but revision is MUCH TOUGHER!! (Especially by the fourth round when I’m wondering what other vocation I should be pursuing…)
Like?
0
Thank you, Anna!!! Your post is an answer to a prayer (the own that goes something like: OMG…No, no ,no, what happened to my perfect beautiful story!!! What can I do, where has it gone, why must this always happen…) It’s so difficult in the midst of floundering at the bottom of the creative well to see past what it particularly lousy on the page at present, and your post was just the boost I needed to remember that the light is there – peeking out just ahead – as long as I keep holding firm to the keyboard and my faith that “this too shall pass,” and the words will come again.
http://www.barbaraforteabate.com
Like?
0
I have pushed through the “crisis point” and gotten to 63,000 words and have stalled out again. I feel so confidant in beginning a story, continuing a story, it’s the ending that’s got me second guessing everything. As my husband says, “But the end is supposed to be the best bit.” I know…argh! But, I’ll get there too.
I love you’re “lion hunt” analogy.
.-= Sarah´s last blog ..What I’ve Learned From Writing a Novel =-.
Like?
0