The Elements of Awe, Part II
Donald Maass on Apr 07 2010 | Filed under: CRAFT
My post last month sprang from research at the University of Pennsylvania into what causes online readers of The New York Times to e-mail articles to friends. Those researchers have done fiction writers a huge favor. They have decoded what generates word of mouth.
The most important finding regards what inspires in the reader a feeling of awe. The researchers defined awe as an “emotion of self-transcendence, a feeling of admiration and elevation in the face of something greater than the self.” Stories that inspire awe have two important dimensions: 1) Their scale is large, and 2) they require of readers “mental accommodation”, meaning they force the reader to view the world in a different way.
Now, I know that some of you right now are racing to congratulate yourselves. My book is long! It’s multi-POV! I’m good on that scale thing. And hey, I rock my readers’ world view! They’ll be shaken to the core!
Oh yeah? When was the last time you read a manuscript or published novel that left you literally shaken to the core? Some time ago?
My point.
Let’s first talk about the reality of scale. High story impact does not come from length alone. It occurs when every character in a novel embarks on a profound journey and every plot layer and sub-plot becomes a novel unto itself. Most novelists don’t work that hard. How do I know? Same way you do. I read the results.
To write on an awe-inspiring scale demands not supreme commitment (everyone with a complete manuscript has that) but the commitment to craft every piece of a novel’s thousands of components with high artistry. That’s work. And that’s the easy part.
The greater challenge is to pull readers into alternate ways of looking at things. This can only be accomplished through characters. First, the reader must bond with them. (See last month’s post.) Next, the character must himself or herself have a unique way of looking at the world.
It’s no wonder, then, that so many commercially successful protagonists are forensic experts, snipers, underwater salvage specialists, surgeons, scientists or vampires. Even a made-up profession like symbologist can involve us in an alternate world view. See the current New York Times best seller list.
But it’s not just about a protagonist with a cool job. Plenty of ordinary people also can capture us. Again, look on the current Times list. There are best sellers about suburban parents, a Southern daughter, a front line soldier in Vietnam, and a seventeen-year-old. Okay, I’ll admit that there’s also Abraham Lincoln (hunting vampires) but you see my point.
Any protagonist with strong opinions, deep convictions, tidal emotions and profound self-regard can transport us out of ourselves as effectively as a Nephilim-fighting nun. But again, it’s work. How to do it? Here are practical tools to help. Ready?
Answer the following questions and apply the answers in your current manuscript:
- What happens in your story that makes your protagonist the most angry? Anticipate that anger three times in the story before the big event.
- What does your protagonist believe beyond all else? Create a story event that forces him or her to accept the opposite.
- What does your hero or heroine see about people that no one else does? Find three times when he or she will notice that thing at work.
- Why does your protagonist’s life matter? At the moment when that’s most true, allow your protagonist to humbly grasp their importance to someone else or to the great scheme of things.
As I’m sure you can see that’s just the beginning. Inspiring awe requires building awesome characters. Is it lots of work? Sure but so is building a house, growing a business or raising a child. We all do that stuff. Why slack off, take shortcuts or merely hope for a passing grade for our fiction?
Donald Maass is president of the Donald Maass Literary Agency in New York. His agency sells more than 150 novels every year to major publishers in the U.S. and overseas. He’s also the author of several craft books for writers, including the highly acclaimed Writing the Breakout Novel and The Fire in Fiction.
Photo courtesy Flickr’s oedipusphinx





















Wow! Just wow! (I hope that’s profound enough for you because I’m at a loss…)
.-= Anne´s last blog ..A.R.S.E.S. =-.
Like?
0
AWESOME! I’m copying and pasting your four points. Now I know where I need to beef up the emotion in my current novel!
Thanks bunches!
.-= Margaret A. Golla´s last blog ..Katie’s Prognosis–not good =-.
Like?
0
Even though I love and trust Therese, when she said this post was phenomenal, I kind of thought it was like a biased mother’s love: WU is her baby, and of course its content is going to seem “phenom” to her.
But no, this post… incredible! Just those 4 questions alone would have been amazing. Perhaps because they are exactly the points I’ve been struggling with and instinctively trying to hone in on for my characters. But now you’ve spelled it out for me, and I know exactly what to tackle.
Thank you!
.-= Kristan´s last blog ..Barcelona sunrise =-.
Like?
0
I’m going to echo all the wows! Wow. Great, great post. What an exceptionally clear distillation of all we fumble around trying to grasp. Thank you!
Like?
0
I really appreciate this whole post, but especially the point about helping readers see the world through different eyes. WATERSHIP DOWN automatically came into mind, along with THE JUNGLE, TALE OF DESPEREAUX, SCREWTAPE LETTERS, and ENDER’S GAME.
I like the description of “large-scale” that you had in WRITING THE BREAKOUT NOVEL. It doesn’t mean THE END OF THE WORLD IS COMING UNLESS WE DO THIS ______(insert hero’s quest). It just means that it has large implications for our protagonists and the people around him/her (like in GILEAD or MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA.)
Great post!
Like?
0
I find it amazing how Donald Maass can dissect a novel, then the protags, and put it in words for other writers. Thanks Therese for the reference. Also, I’m curious. Has Mr. Maass read every book on the NY Times best seller list? I would love to know the answer. All best!
Like?
0
Great post. Makes you want to up your game.
Is this awe inspiring?
No?
Delete.
Like?
0
That second bullet point just sparked my little fuse. Thanks!
Like?
0
[...] Writer Unboxed » Blog Archive » The Elements of Awe, Part II. [...]
Like?
0
Just as I’m working on deepening my characters, someone pointed me to this post–Thank you, Donald Maass, god of the written word, thank you.
Like?
0
this is excellent and very inspiring. thank you to Donald Maass for this powerful advice. i will be considering it all when i sit down to work this afternoon – especially bullet point one.
.-= denice´s last blog ..today i am grateful for… =-.
Like?
0
Printing . . . taping to the wall . . .
.-= Tracy Hahn-Burkett´s last blog ..Pizza and Pancakes =-.
Like?
0
That was very interesting insight on how to make your novel larger than life. I’m curious about how you would attempt to write a very intimate, personal story, which would be awe-inspiring at the same time. These notions seem to be contradicting to me, I’d like to have your opinion on that. Maybe a future article or recommended readings?
.-= Benoit Lelievre´s last blog ..The Elements Of Awe Part 2 =-.
Like?
0
This seems like an oversimplification to me. I’ve heard this before about short fiction too. They say character is the key to generating that complete investment in a work from our readers.
Well that’s true, but character is just one way to do it, and it’s the most classic way to do it, and it’s the easiest way to do it. There are other profound things that fiction can do besides giving you an interesting character. There are other ways that the world can be shown differently. I don’t pretend to understand it all, but writing is so much more than this. For me, it’s all about generating interest, that sort of profound interest. Think about all of the ways that it happens for yourself.
If allegory, news stories, jokes, and amazing sports plays can move people, then I’m sure that there’s more to this than “Any protagonist with strong opinions, deep convictions, tidal emotions and profound self-regard.”
Like?
0
Hello Don,
Great post, (made notes). Reminded me of one of your exciting Master Classes in Surrey. Miss those days.
Well done as always. Thanks for sharing your wisdom.
All the best.
Daryl
.-= Daryl Sedore´s last blog ..Procrastinate Tomorrow, or Don’t Write At All =-.
Like?
0
Not only have you made me think, you’ve made me rush back to revise my manuscript (and I’m just 8 days from deadline). But it will be worth it. Thanks.
Like?
0
As always, Donald Maass has a wonderful way of framing the things that make fiction emotionally gripping for readers, then offering specific, do-able strategies that help push our craftsmanship to tap into those elements.
Joe Scott, I admit to being confused by your comment that this focus on characterization is ‘the easiest’ way to do it’ [i.e. create investment on the part of the reader.] I don’t know many authors who say they find it ‘easy.’
I do agree, though, that plumbing the depths of characters’ emotional lives and testing their beliefs about the world is only *one* of the ways to engage readers. I think it’s an incredibly powerful one, though, and saw this essay as a discussion of this element, not a statement that it is the only element.
Like?
0
It’s one thing to understand these principles, another to impart them in a way that others can understand, and yet a third to inspire belief they can be achieved. Don’t know how you do it so consistently, Mr. Maass, but I’m grateful.
.-= hope101´s last blog ..One Good Egg Makes a Bad Easter Omelet =-.
Like?
0
Thank you for sharing from your bottomless vat of wisdom ;)
Like?
0
You make it all clear and easy to understand. *thump on the head * I see my characters so clearly and feel their emotions. I can see where there is a breakdown between my thoughts and the paper. The four questions that help with character development are brilliant.
Thank you,
Like?
0
Oddly, while I think my book has oodles of awe, rage for the protagonist, and a new way of viewing the world… or the solar system, as it’s sci fi :)
It almost exclusively is from the point of view of a single charachter, there are breif moments with pov’s from others, but for the most part it’s all from one.
How required is it in modern works that you have multiple protagonists?
Like?
0
Teenagers see the world in ways the mere adults don’t, one reason for YA’s popularity. My two main characters are teenagers. based on my own kids. When I’m stuck for material I ask them, “What do you think of this?” Their answers always surprise me.
But this post brings it to another level, one in which I can gauge their responses and decide, “Awe-inspiring or merely hormonal?”
Thanks Don!!!!!
.-= Birgitte Necessary´s last blog ..Critique vs. Criticism: Where is the Line? =-.
Like?
0
You’ve no idea how helpful this was to me tonight. I’ve been agonizing about a subplot in my book and whether or not to tackle it or go easy on myself and make it go away. I’m running away from “easy” and straight into the thick of the conflict that this issue will create. Thanks for the nudge.
.-= Erika Robuck´s last blog ..Warm Ups: Figurative Language in Wolf Hall =-.
Like?
0
Thanks, Don, for such a thought-provoking article. I’ve printed it out and will take a look at those questions this weekend.
Thanks again.
Like?
0
This was the sentence that struck me most forcefully: “When was the last time you read a manuscript or published novel that left you literally shaken to the core?”
Oh, how I long to read a story like that!
Like?
0
Just last night finished reading WRITING THE BREAKOUT NOVEL, so what a treat to wake up to read your post!
I echo Lia’s sentiments…
Thank you for this article. Will reread as many times as needed.
.-= Marisa Birns´s last blog ..Avocation =-.
Like?
0
Thank you for such a great post. I love the analogy of building a novel is like building a house. Perfect. Only a novel takes longer.
J
Judy’s blog Writers Riding Right
http://www.jridgley.wordpress.com
help for those historicals out there.
Like?
0
“Oh yeah? When was the last time you read a manuscript or published novel that left you literally shaken to the core? Some time ago?”
God, I love the books that change me/awe me: One Hundred Years of Solitude, The Odyssey, To the Lighthouse…and more recently, Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close. When I’m writing, I often think of the characters Jonathan Safran Foer created and the intricacies of his subplots. Holy cow, that was work.
Great post. Got me all revved up.
.-= Kristin Bair O’Keeffe´s last blog ..How (Not) to Talk to Adoptive Families: Part II =-.
Like?
0
So wise, so clear, so essential…so hard(not always…just most of the time.) This is precisely the sort of lesson I need to re-commit to action everytime I sit down to edit — which is pretty much always. Donald Maass has once again given perfect advice, profound as it is essential for any of us in passionate pursuit of creating “stand-out-from-the-shelf” writing.
http://www.barbaraforteabate.com
Like?
0
Finding a novel to read that shakes you to the core is a challenge, working to write one brings me back to keyboard every day. Thank you for the insights.
Like?
0
Just what I needed! Thank you. I immediately went to Amazon and bought two of your books (I know… I should’ve done that LONG ago!) ha.
Then I printed out this post and worked out the answers to each bullet point for my WIP.
Thanks. Much appreciated.
.-= Margo Kelly´s last blog ..Henry’s Box =-.
Like?
0
Now, finding someone who’s published and has done this would be quite a trick, but I concur it’s an admirable goal as is redemption in a character. I have duel redemptions in both of my yet to be sold thrillers.
.-= Mark A. York´s last blog ..Jones cleared of scientific fraud =-.
Like?
0
[...] far in this series I’ve discussed character strength, evoking high emotion, story scale and awe…which is to say, giving the reader (or really, your characters) new ways of seeing, feeling, [...]
Like?
0
You give me hope that somebody’s going to want to publish something of mine someday, because these four points that you mention are already intrinsic and automatic to my writing. Here’s to the future.
Like?
0
[...] Writer Unboxed » Blog Archive » The Elements of Awe, Part II. This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. ← Poetry Course On Writing for Teens → [...]
Like?
0