To Tweet or Not to Tweet…
Allison Winn Scotch on Apr 09 2009 | Filed under: Business
It seems like every day, I hear of a new social media tool that, as a writer, I am told that I MUST be on. The latest, of course, is Twitter, and I’m not the only one. In the past year alone, Twitter has grown by an astounding 1342%, which means that every day, thousands of users are getting their tweets on. The question remains: productive tool for writers or just another time suck?
My conclusion after diving in? Hmmmm, unsure. Probably a little bit of both.
I’ll admit up front that I was very, very dubious about Twitter. I already have a blog, which I use strictly for professional purposes, and I’m already on Facebook, which I use strictly for personal purposes (I don’t friend people whom I don’t know, etc), and this, to be honest, was enough for me. The blog allows me to disseminate marketing info as needed, and Facebook allows me to keep up with friends whom I otherwise wouldn’t have. So…where does Twitter fall into the mix?
Backtrack just a little: for those of you who don’t yet tweet (what updates on Twitter are called), Twitter is essentially just a tool for you to provide bulleted shots of “what are you doing right now?,” akin to those Facebook status updates, but unlike on FB, people tweet often – numerous times a day, citing what they’re doing, where they are, forwarding on information from other Tweeters, passing along links that they deem important or just entertaining. That, in a nutshell, this is Twitter. That’s it! Another difference between Twitter and Facebook, and this is a big one, is that anyone can see your tweets, unless you create a private profile, so conceivably, the breadth of your reach – marketing-wise – could be much wider. AND, you do not have to reciprocate friendships, so unlike on FB, in which you see all of your friends’ info and vice versa, if someone follows you, you do not have to follow them. Which, actually, I like because I can control the flow of information that comes my way.
Okay, so with that out of the way, here is my experience: I’ve slowly warmed up to Twitter, though the jury is out on whether or not it is imperative. I signed up several months ago when fellow writers were urging me to, claiming it was a tool that I simply couldn’t live with out. Huh? Really? But I created an account and waited for the magic to happen…and it didn’t. I didn’t really see the purpose of filling people in on the minutia of my day, and I definitely didn’t need to read about theirs. I also found the Twitter home page really confusing and overwhelming, and those Twitter acronyms? Forget it. My brain had a meltdown.
But a week or so ago, I resolved one last time to give Twitter a chance.
The first thing I did, and this was very, very helpful, was install Tweetdeck, which organizes your tweets into manageable masses. It also helps you respond, forward and direct message your followers, which takes a lot of the scary acronyms and symbols out of the equation. From there, I tried to figure out just what the heck I’m using it for! I think that using it entirely to pimp my blog or promote a book defeats the purpose: one of the things I’ve found most fun about Twitter is getting tiny glimpses into other people’s lives (which, I know, contradicts my above statement about hearing about minutia), but hey, I’ll admit that it’s great fun to read what John Mayer is doing at this exact moment. So I’ve been playing around with a combination of work-related tweets and a few personal observations, while not making it too personal because again, you simply don’t know who is reading your posts. I’ve been told that the best way to build your followers is to tweet things that are then retweeted (RT) by your followers. I suppose posting interesting links about the publishing industry might get this done, but I haven’t yet mastered this, which is fine by me. My goal is not to have 1000000000 followers.
I think if I were still a magazine writer, I’d find Twitter a lot more useful for strictly work purposes. I can see how you could post a source question and have it retweeted all over the Twitter universe, or come up with story ideas from followers’ random musings. But as an author, I think the only thing this is really good for (and I can be convinced otherwise), is spreading your name, voice and general readership awareness. Which shouldn’t be underestimated. But also might not be worth the time I’m spending on there. We’ll see. Talk to me when I have a book launch, because then, yes, I could see where Twitter might make a difference.
For now, I’m enjoying it for what it is, and trying NOT to get sucked in the way that I do on Facebook. But I’m curious to hear your Twitter experiences – ways that it’s worked for you, and ways that it hasn’t. And if you’re tweeting, come find me: @aswinn.com.






















Great post, Allison. I, too, downloaded Tweetdeck recently, and found it incredibly helpful for organizing peeps and for retweating without worrying about acronyms. And, like you, I’m warming up to Twitter, though I didn’t like it at first; Tweetdeck has everything to do with this change of heart.
Anyone else out there tweet? I’m at @theresewalsh
Like?
0
Oh man. I’ve been resisting Twitter because I’m the type of person who has no discipline when it comes to stuff like this. Still, I concede it is probably useful, especially when it comes to promotion.
Maybe I’ll dip a toe in soon and sent ya’ll some Tweets.
Like?
0
I was NOT a Twitter fan when I first started, partly because I was just finishing up a manuscript for my editor and so life was not at all tweet-worthy. How many times can you say “still in my pj’s…need a shower” and assume anyone could possibly care?
Since then, though, I’ve warmed up to it. Like you, I enjoy the glimpses into people’s lives. And having it on my iPhone gives me something fun to check out when I’m waiting to the get oil in the car changed, etc.
Not sure how it works for book promotion, but it does seem like a fun way to let people in on the fun side of the business–meeting with my agent or editor, doing a book event–without the formality of writing a full blog post.
I’m @Trishryan
Like?
0
I’ve had a similar experience, Allison. One thing I’ve really been enjoying about Twitter, though, is that it reminds me that there is this whole book community out there. I like that I can find other people who are just as interested as I am in talking about books and the publishing industry. My problem is I am not yet sure how you can make real connections in 140 characters. That said, I’m not giving up just yet. Maybe there is something to be said for brevity.
And for those of you who tweet, I’m at @juliebux
Like?
0
I’m with you, pretty ambivalent.
I originally registered with Twitter (and MySpace, which I sort of hate…) “just in case.” Just in case I ever need it for marketing my future books. ;P
But I thought I’d never use either. Nor did I want to, because I ALREADY waste too much time online. (I just started using Google Reader for all my blogs, though, and that’s a HUGE help!)
Anyway, now I like posting random updates to Twitter instead of my blog (because how annoying are a constant stream of one-line posts? :P) but I hate having to “listen in” on other people’s constant Twitter-conversations. In fact, I de-friend people who are basically just replying to other people’s tweets all day long, because seriously, that’s what EMAIL is for.
Your point about magazine writers is a good one, and something I hadn’t thought of. So I guess Twitter may actually be useful for some people, but for me right now it’s just an outlet for my random thoughts.
Like?
0
I started using Twitter on the recommendation of a writer friend–she’s my age and not one to jump at every new thing–and still have mixed feelings about it. I’m very selective in who I follow, but it’s neat to keep up with friends. Don’t know how valuable a marketing tool it is, although I may find out when my book is published next year.
As for Facebook, I have my tweets forwarded to that site but almost never go there. Too crowded, and I’ve made the mistake of “friending” a bunch of people because we have many, many mutual friends. Didn’t want to inadvertently hurt any feelings.
I’ll be interested in what everyone else thinks about this. Thanks, Allison, for getting the ball rolling.
Like?
0
I’ve used Twitter on and off for a couple of years but I never appreciated the value in it until I attended a blogging conference. I was shocked to see that everyone there was on Twitter, using it as THE primary source of connection to not only family and friends, but more importantly, to their audience.
I’ve been watching Ashton Kuther tweet for a month now and at this point, he’s got something like 700,000 followers. His success not only stems from simply being Ashton Kutcher, but because he’s able to showcase exactly how charming he is. (Who knew?) Plus, his followers are hooked because he responds to regular folks’ tweets, and not just famous ones like John Mayer. Honestly, I never gave him any thought before, but now I’m actually interested to pay to see whatever he’s got coming out next. Mission accomplished, Kelso.
Twitter works well for me for a couple of reasons. Since I write memoir, readers appreciate hearing some of the day to day stuff in real time. Also, the viral nature of it has brought me a lot of new followers. I friend everyone who asks and I like having a medium where I don’t have to exclude anyone for privacy reasons. (Personally, I’m unable to spill secrets in less than 140 characters.)
I use Twitter to supplement my promotion efforts and I’ve seen my web traffic grow 25% since I started back on it. (Book sales have followed suit.) Also, I enjoy being able to connect with my audience. I write for them, so having instant feedback is invaluable. Plus, so much of my inspiration comes from observing others, so Twitter is the perfect “rear window.”
Finally, as a writer, I dig anything that gives me an opportunity to procrastinate…
I am @altgeldshrugged.
Like?
0
Like most, I was skeptical at first (“Why would anyone care what I’m doing right now?”). But it’s not for reporting the minutiae of one’s day. It’s a way to share part of yourself with the world in a casual, friendly manner.
I love it because it’s kind of a one-stop shop for staying in touch with friends, keeping track of news, sharing my writing process, and occasionally announcing the latest book event.
Because I work at home, I don’t get much human interaction, so Twitter acts as a sort of virtual office (without the politics and bad coffee). I turn it off when I’m writing, because I need a quiet mind, but at other times, it’s good for my mental health to have that back-and-forth conversation.
I also love its simplicity—there’s not much to customize and therefore not much to obsess over. The entire focus is on people’s thoughts and the sharing thereof.
(Also, the two main characters from my urban fantasy series are both on Twitter, as themselves, which is a fun way to develop the characters and give readers a closer connection.)
Re: Twitter as book promo:
The key with Twitter, as with any interactive forum, is to build relationships. Be a real person, not an ad. Talk to people. Respond to their tweets and reply to their responses to yours. I don’t think of it as a billboard for my cleverness or my latest book; I think of it as a way to make new friends. I believe that with any kind of “networking” (ugh, I hate that word), relationships should always come first—be a nice person and the rest will follow. Or if you can’t be nice, be entertaining. ;-)
Oh, and I’m at http://twitter.com/jsmithready
Like?
0
at other times, it’s good for my mental health to have that back-and-forth conversation.
Jeri, I’ve noticed this, too. And it’s kind of cool to feel like you’re part of a big room of people who are doing the same thing.
Like?
0
I’m loving it. I am a social creature. Writing is such a lonesome endeavor. I need the contact with people.
I use TweetDeck. It was the third software I tried and I’m LOVING it.
Look for me!
http://twitter.com/ArkansasCyndi
Like?
0
I love Twitter for some odd reason. I sidled into it–my son tweeted and it was a fun way to know what was up with him, since he lived in NYC and I lived in Colorado. A newspaper invited local bloggers to Tweet through the elections, so I came out of the closet, and almost immediately found it very useful and a great tool, and well….fun. I like the insights into daily life, and the simplicity of communication.
I haven’t tried TweetDeck, but now I definitely will.
http://twitter.com/awriterafoot
Like?
0
Jeri wrote:
“The key with Twitter, as with any interactive forum, is to build relationships. Be a real person, not an ad. Talk to people. Respond to their tweets and reply to their responses to yours. I don’t think of it as a billboard for my cleverness or my latest book; I think of it as a way to make new friends. I believe that with any kind of “networking” (ugh, I hate that word), relationships should always come first—be a nice person and the rest will follow. Or if you can’t be nice, be entertaining.”
Very smart. The whole goal of social media, in one fine paragraph.
Like?
0
Like many of the other readers I signed up with Twitter many months ago and didn’t really use my account until recently. Now I’m hooked.
I run a bunch of blogs and it is quickly becoming my best source of traffic. Twitter has a great API so you can automate a lot of the Twitter tasks like adding and removing friends, tweeting your most recent blog post, etc. I’ve got a seperate Twitter account for each blog and many of them I never even check, they just grow and people find my automated tweets and click over to my websites.
My most used Twitter account is for my screenwriting blog and aside from showcasing my blog posts it’s been a great format for interaction. People ask me questions and I typically answer them and they most likely check out my blog and become loyal readers.
I do searches on Twitter for people tweeting about their “screenplay” and then I friend them and they most likely friend me back (all of this is automated so it takes zero time) so my account is growing pretty quickly with a good following of people interested in my topic.
I also have Tweetie on my iPhone so I can answer Tweets when ever I have a spare moment.
I only follow people interested in screenwriting so I don’t think I waste any time on it either. Perhaps I’ll create another account if I ever want to follow just a few friends.
I haven’t used Tweetdeck but after reading all these comments I’m going to download it and check it out.
I’m on Twitter at @ashleymeyers
Like?
0
Have just jumped into Twitter and like many of you, apprehensive. Going to check out TweetDeck – thanks for the recommendation.
I’m on Twitter at @soulistry and have started a Twibe (Twitter Tribe aka ‘group’) called ArtAndSoul
So many Twitter applications and not enough hours in the day to become familiar with them which is why referrals are so helpful. ;-)
I’m on Twitter at @soulistry
And I’ve started a Twibe (Twitter Tribe aka ‘group’) called ArtAndSoul
Like?
0