Love Me, Love My Book?
Therese Walsh on Nov 18 2008 | Filed under: REAL WORLD
Writing is a pretty private enterprise, so while I’m active within my community, many in my city never knew I was writing a book–or what it was about–or that it had sold. They learned all about it, though, after my local press decided to write an article about me and Unbounded. It appeared recently as a feel-good story on the front page of the entertainment section on a Sunday, and was even picked up by two other upstate NY AP presses–a decent circulation in all…and a lot of local eyes on me, all at once.
The outpouring of support stunned me. Strangers emailed through the blog with kind words, neighbors called. I heard from my fourth-grade teacher and the head of the local arts council. Even my doctor routed a copy of the feature to me with words of encouragement attached via sticky note.
I felt uplifted by all of this until the day I went to my 13-year-old daughter’s swim-meet party and was surrounded by her friends. These kids, many of whom grew up hearing my stories starting in the 3′s class in preschool, were ecstatic over my success.
They were also adamant that they’d buy my book.
Well, hell. There are words worse than ‘hell’ in my book. And plot points less kid-friendly than bleepable words. This story isn’t like the ones they may remember, full of monsters who don’t like cheese and fields of dapper green. My unease ratcheted up a notch when I heard similar vows of readerly support from my son’s 10-year-old friends.
“There are dark parts to the story,” I explained to one mother. “It’s not really appropriate for kids.”
“Kids sometimes don’t notice dark parts,” she said.
“Oh, they’ll notice.”
She frowned.
“If it was a movie, it would be rated R.”
It’s not just about the kids, either. I’m not sure what to say when an ultra-conservative acquaintance, a woman who never shows more than an inch of flesh and who sends her children to bible camp for six weeks every summer, says she’s excited to read my book. Nod? Say thank you? Issue an immediate warning that the book contains some sex, violence and profanity? I mean, nothing’s in there that doesn’t need to be in there, and it’s not Debbie Does Dallas (for which at least one of my friends will be disappointed), but I’m not sure she’d like it. Then again, maybe she would. Unbounded is also a story about acceptance and unlimited love and conquering demons and finding home. And my mother–who might have liked to send me to bible camp every summer–loved it.
Book two isn’t going to be any better. One character, already firmly in my head, is a serious cusser. Should I put a muzzle on her just in case one of my kiddos’ friends picks up the book? No, of course I shouldn’t. This work isn’t for children or ‘tweens.
But still…
I’m sure every new author goes through this sort of thing–the jitters that come with realizing people are not only going to have access to your book but may judge you for what you’ve written. And some of those people will know you very, very well. You’ll have to pass them on the street. Meet with them at parent-teacher conferences. You’ll see them at the grocery store. On the soccer field. You’ll hope they approve, but maybe they won’t. And you’ll have to be okay with that, too.
I’m also sure the answer is to keep on keepin’ on and try not to think about any of that. Serve the work, not the neighbors or their children. Let them decide for themselves–or with their parents–if the book is right for them, just like they would over any other product.
Do you think about these sorts of issues when you write? Have you ever written something and had someone respond to it in a surprising way? How do you think the issue of personal character plays into all of this, if it does? Care to share any words of wisdom for the uninitiated, need-to-grow-thicker-skin folk, among us?
Write on, all!





















i’ve heard a few anecdotes about the harsh, critical and condemning few that come out of the woodwork when you get published. But if any youngster wants to buy your book, just ask them to promise to give it as a gift to a favorite adult in their life. i guess it must be wierd when, having lived a solitary writer’s life, that after being published, you yourself feel like an open book!!! but it’s all good, ter!!!
Like?
0
Yes, definitely a concern, and I’ve seen a friend go through a whirlwind of hell for what he wrote and published. But what I learned from his experience is that your true friends will stick with you, even when they disagree, and the rest of the world be damned. As writers I think we can’t let ourselves get too intimidated by potential negative response. We should be aware of it, and we shouldn’t necessarily try to provoke it, but we can’t let it stop us from writing our truths — whether non-fiction, romance, historical, fantasy, or plain old fiction.
Despite that nonchalant mentality, I do not look forward to the day I lose friends (or potential friends) over something I’ve written…
Like?
0
Well, you warned the moms that it’s rated R. If they chose not to heed the warning, then you’ve done all you can.
But you have to write your truth, and let the chips fall.
And if someone does have a problem with it, then you’ll know you elicited an emotional response, and that’s pretty cool too. :-)
Like?
0
I know just what you mean. It’s really uncomfortable when worlds of fiction and reality collide. I live a very sweet ‘G’ rated life, but my fiction would qualify for ‘R’.
Like?
0
As a writer of sexy romance (and also the mother of a 13-year-old daughter and 10-year-old son) I have been through this same experience since Line of Scrimmage came out in September. I’ve been unpleasantly surprised by people I never would’ve expected to be prudish acting shocked about the sex and then pleasantly surprised by people such as my 77-year-old aunt who said, “the sexier the better.” I’ve learned to not let it bother me when people seem put off by the sex. I also like to point out that mine is TAME compared to what’s out there, but to people who don’t read the romance genre as a rule, mine is hardly tame.
My daughter’s friends want to read it (hell, SHE wants to read it) and I just keep saying they can read it in seven years when they are 20. Not one minute before.
Try not to let what anyone says take ONE bit away from the excitement of having your book published. You can’t change what people say or do. Like all things, the only thing we control is how we react to it. Best of luck to you during this very exciting time!
Like?
0
Thea, yes, that’s one possible solution. I like Marie’s, too; tell them to come back when they’re of age.
Kristan, your friend’s experience sounds like a worst-case scenario. I’m sorry for him. I agree with what you said about intimidation; it doesn’t jive with creation at all.
Kath, that’s a smart way to look at it: emotional response = good.
Lauri, I wonder if people with X-rated lives would write G-rated fiction. Hmmm… ;-)
Marie, thanks so much for sharing your story and for your encouraging words.
Like?
0